News from the Alaska State Legislature, the Office of Senator Coghill
For Immediate Release: October 02, 2017

Senators Disappointed by 9th Circuit’s Decision in Water Rights Case

Coghill_stamp.jpgSenator John Coghill
  ~ Send Email
  ~ Web Site

ANCHORAGE – Members of the Alaska Senate Majority today expressed disappointment with the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision in Sturgeon v. Masica, a case centered on Alaskans’ right to manage their navigable waterways. 

The court ruled that the federal government “properly exercised its authority to regulate hovercraft use on the rivers within conservation system units in Alaska” when it prevented John Sturgeon from using his hovercraft to access moose hunting grounds.

“I’m disappointed but not surprised,” said Sen. John Coghill, R-North Pole. “The plain language of the law was acknowledged by the US Supreme Court and, yet again, ignored by the 9th Circuit. The U.S. Supreme Court has previously said that the 9th Circuit’s interpretation of ANILCA, Section 103(c) was inconsistent with both the text and context of ANILCA.”

The ruling is subject to review by the U.S. Supreme Court, which overturned a significant number of decisions from the 9th Circuit in recent years.  

"This decision exemplifies the 9th Circuit's lack of understanding about the State of Alaska and its sovereignty over our land and waters,” said Sen. Cathy Giessel, R-Anchorage. “As a result, this segment of the judicial branch is rewriting existing law based on a lack of information. I remain hopeful that the Supreme Court will overturn this decision.”

For more information, contact Senate Majority Press Secretary Daniel McDonald at (907) 465-4066.

###

icon-facebook.png Share Share this on Twitter Tweet

News & Videos more >

Senator Bert Stedman

Let’s Protect the Permanent Fund & Guarantee a Dividend

SITKA – Sen Bert Stedman (R-Sitka) introduced a constitutional amendment today for consideration in the upcoming legislative session to protect the Permanent Fund and guarantee a...  Full Story >>

Senator Bert Stedman

Petersburg Land Grant Bill Signed into Law

SB 28 was sponsored by Sen Bert Stedman (R-Sitka) to increase the Petersburg Borough’s land entitlement to 14,666 acres When the Petersburg Borough was created by the voters in 2013 they...  Full Story >>

Senator Peter Micciche

Senate Toughens Criminal Law

JUNEAU - Today, by a vote of 11 to 8, the Alaska Senate concurred with the House changes to Senate Bill 54 SB54 toughens Alaska criminal laws reversing some provisions of Senate Bill 91 passed...  Full Story >>

Senator Cathy Giessel

Chairs Announce Working Group Members, Formation of Advisory Group

ANCHORAGE – The co-chairs of the legislative working group created by House Bill 111, Sen Cathy Giessel (R-Anchorage) and Rep Geran Tarr (D-Anchorage), announced today the working...  Full Story >>

Senator Cathy Giessel

Senators Call on Lt. Gov. Mallot to Fight Ballot Box Biology

ANCHORAGE – Today, members of the Alaska Senate Majority urged Lt Gov Byron Mallott to appeal a recent ruling allowing an unconstitutional initiative to proceed...  Full Story >>

Senator John Coghill

Senators Disappointed by 9th Circuit’s Decision in Water Rights Case

ANCHORAGE – Members of the Alaska Senate Majority today expressed disappointment with the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision in Sturgeon v Masica, a case centered on Alaskans’...  Full Story >>

Senator Lyman Hoffman

Sen. Hoffman Thanks DOT for Swift Response to Bethel Highway Needs

BETHEL – Sen Lyman Hoffman, D-Bethel, today thanked Marc Luiken, Commissioner of the Alaska Department Transportation and Public Facilities (DOT), for the Walker...  Full Story >>

Senator Pete Kelly

Statement from Sen. Kelly on Special Session Proclamation

FAIRBANKS – Sen Pete Kelly, R-Fairbanks, President of the Alaska Senate, today released the following statement in response to Gov Bill Walker’s proclamation convening the 30th...  Full Story >>

Senator Pete Kelly

Senators Respond to Ahtna’s Rejection of Klutina Settlement

FAIRBANKS – Members of the Alaska Senate Majority today responded to Ahtna, Inc ’s rejection of the Walker administration’s proposed settlement regarding public access to...  Full Story >>

Senator Cathy Giessel

Bill Ending Cash Payments to Oil & Gas Companies Becomes Law

JUNEAU – Today, Gov Bill Walker signed House Bill 111 into law, legislation that ends the state's program of cash payments to companies in the oil and gas industry...  Full Story >>

Find your Senator full map